Between now and New Year’s, plenty of your customers will order holiday catering, gift cards, or a quick dinner by searching your name and tapping the first link they see. This fall, security researchers found hundreds of fake ordering sites built to catch exactly those customers. The fake site shows your real menu, takes the order, and keeps the card number. You never see the order, but you may get the angry phone call. Here’s what was found, why it matters for independent restaurants and shops in New York City and Westchester, and a 15-minute check to run before the holiday rush.
What researchers found
On November 5, 2026, the fraud research firm InfoHawk published a report it calls “Scamwich” (opens in a new tab). Across two research passes it found 820 web addresses impersonating 35 U.S. restaurant brands, including Jimmy John’s, Chipotle, Firehouse Subs and Dave’s Hot Chicken. Of those, 808 ended in .delivery, with misspelled names that look close enough at a glance.
These weren’t crude copies. The sites pulled pages straight from each restaurant’s real website, so the menu and ordering flow looked and worked normally. Only the checkout was swapped out. It asked for the customer’s card details and, in some cases, the one-time text message code their bank sent to approve the payment. The browser even showed “Connection is secure,” because the scammers had a valid security certificate. The padlock only means the connection is encrypted. It doesn’t mean the site belongs to the restaurant.
InfoHawk traced at least 47 Google Search ads pointing to these sites between July and October 2026. The ads had stopped by early November, but 367 of the sites were still online on November 4. The researchers also stress that the real restaurants’ websites weren’t hacked. The scammers didn’t need to break in at all.
It isn’t only the big chains
Small, single-owner shops get copied too. Hoodline reports (opens in a new tab) that the owner of Boichik Bagels, a Bay Area bagel shop, found four fake versions of her online store. They used her photos, logo and customer reviews, and offered everything at 65 percent off. One address differed from the real one by a single letter. A longtime customer spotted the first one, and new copies kept appearing after she sent takedown requests. A Proofpoint researcher quoted in that coverage said she had identified roughly 50,000 websites using designs copied from legitimate stores.
For a neighborhood restaurant or shop, the damage lands in familiar places. A customer “paid” and the food never came. Staff can’t find the order or the charge. Someone leaves a one-star review blaming you for a sale you never made, and their card details are now in a criminal’s hands.
A 15-minute holiday check
None of this needs special tools. Grab a phone and run through this list before the busiest weeks start.
- Search yourself like a customer. On a phone, search your business name plus “order online,” “delivery,” and “gift card.” Look at the ads at the top as well as the regular results. Write down any address that isn’t yours, but don’t enter anything on it.
- Give customers one official link. Make sure your Google Business Profile, website, Instagram bio, printed menus and table QR codes all point to the same real ordering page. The fewer places people have to guess, the better.
- Lock the accounts that control that link. Turn on two-step sign-in for your Google Business Profile, website, domain registrar and online ordering platform. If someone gets into one of those, they can swap your real link for a fake one.
- Prepare your staff for the phone call. When a customer says they paid and nothing arrived, ask for the website address they used and a screenshot of the receipt. If it’s a copycat, tell them politely to call their bank right away, and pass the details to the manager.
- Report what you find. Send fake sites to your online ordering provider, report fake ads to Google, and report the address to the company that registered the domain. Hoodline notes that ICANN’s guidance is to start with the registrar. Warn customers on your own social accounts, but describe the fake site rather than linking to it.
- Tell customers what you’ll never ask for. A short line on your site or receipts, such as “We’ll never ask for the code your bank texts you,” helps people stop before they type it in.
Retail shops selling gift cards or holiday items online should run the same check. The Boichik copies were online stores, not food ordering pages.
Where Overwatch One fits
Copycat sites live outside your four walls, which is why nobody tends to own the problem. Our restaurant IT work covers the accounts and systems around your POS and online ordering, along with Wi-Fi and cameras. With IT as a Service, businesses across New York City and Westchester County, NY get two-step sign-in set up on the accounts that matter, plus a team to call when a customer reports something strange. If you want a second set of eyes before the holidays, start with a cybersecurity assessment, get in touch, or Ask Scott, our AI assistant.
Sources
- InfoHawk: Scamwich: Inside a Restaurant Delivery Payment-Skimming Campaign, Nov 5, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Hoodline: Boichik Bagels Owner Finds Four Fake Websites Targeting Customer Card Data, Nov 3, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Source Defense: Restaurant Customers Are Ordering From Criminals, Not the Brands They Chose, Nov 13, 2026 (opens in a new tab)
Details are from the linked sources as checked on November 17, 2026 and may change. This guide is independent and isn’t sponsored or reviewed by InfoHawk, Hoodline, Source Defense, Proofpoint, Google, or any restaurant brand named. Product and company names belong to their owners.







